When I got my first Snow Trac, a factory original Red ST4 with the original 36 HP(40 HP industrial), I was showing it off to a bunch of guy's in the Boeing Jeep club. There reaction was something along the line of:" GNARLY RIG, but you better get a Winch".
Having grown up in New England and having skiied alot in New Hampshine, Vermont and Mass I don't remember seeing many Snow Cats equipped with winches. So we Tried to get it stuck, attacked every steep hill we could find in the Cascades all around Mt. Ranieer, MT. St. Helens, McKenzie Pass in Oregon and a whole list of other places. Later as my collection grew to a dozen Snow Cats we tried, tested and pushed the machines to their limits. A stock Snow Track is about equivalent to a stock snow mobile, it can hold it's own. A Tucker Steel track can often out climb a Snow Trac. BUT practally nothing seems to out preform a stock Trac Master or Snow Master. I'm sure it has to do with the power to weight ratio and the positioning of the drive.
When it comes to Gnarly terraine a Kristy can hold it's own pretty good too. When I worked for Alyeska, the Trans Alaska Pipeline, they had Bombardiere Ski Dozer's with 2 sets of tracks, Steel Tall Grouser, and Aluminum with a rubber edge 'summer tracks'. These didn't preform very well despite having the Turbo Cummings Diesel. Alyeska also had Tucker 1543's. These would easily out preform the bombardier's. The Tuckers had aluminum grousers on rubber belting. At one point Aleyska had some 40+ of these Tuckers. Before that they had Snow Tracs and Snow Masters. Under certain conditions it is possible to drive a Snow Master straight up until it flips over. At an Ice covered river crossing outsides Fairbanks there were: Tucker, Thiokol, Bombardier and an Army Weasel all of which could not make it up this one hill. Along comes a Trac Master, drives right up, and left the other snow cat owners cursing:"Show off! #@*%#!!....." because he was dragging 2 Moose behind him and they were not even on a sled!
I've also seen some of the really big Groomers, mostly Bombardier and Piston Bully (Kossborer) that were close to 20 Foot wide and cost 400,000 $ do quite well on steep terraine in New snow. In a competition I would be willing to bet that a 35 year old Trac Master would still place in the top 4 against 2007 Machines, and an old steel track tucker would still be a contender. We pulled a 3/4 ton Dodge Turbo Cummings diesel with a heavy camper and a car trailer behind that, up a 9 or 10 % grade for several miles in 2 feet of snow with a 1963 Tucker Steel track that had the original 94 HP dodge Flat Haed Six. The Truck, Trailer and Camper weighed over 10,000 LBs, the Tucker only 3500. It didn't even overheat! Snow was pushing over the hood of the truck and the dual axel car trailer was dragging along like a surf board behind the truck.